Columns by John

John Brown has been a wine and food columnist in West Virginia since the 1980’s. His regular columns appear in the Charleston (WV) Gazette-Mail under the title Vines & Vittles.

Can anyone make a good chardonnay?

Can anyone make a good chardonnay?

I have to admit, I have been very critical in recent years about how certain winemakers, usually from
California, vinify perhaps the greatest of all white wines - chardonnay. In a word, too many chardonnays are “overdone.”

How? Well, some chardonnay growers allow the grapes to get overripe on the vine which produces not only hot, high alcohol wines, but also ones that lack balancing acidity.  Then, many of these same wines are put in new wood barrels and allowed to absorb huge amounts of oak flavors, completely overwhelming the fruit and producing a wine that doesn’t even resemble something that once actually grew on a vine.

What you’re left with is a beverage that’s about as subtle as “White Lightnin' ” without the benefit of corn liquor’s kick! And forget about matching the stuff with food unless your tastes run to dishes like anaconda and habanero casserole.
Now, I am not the first wine writer to criticize chardonnay made in this bombastic manner, but I may be one of the first to complain about the knee-jerk response to this style by other wine makers.  I refer to them as the ascetic school of chardonnay producers.
These guys have ridden the pendulum to the other extreme, making some of the most austere, acidic and painfully bland chardonnay in a pitiful attempt to capitalize on the criticism with the overblown stuff.
Help!  Is there anyone out there who can restore sanity and a sense of balance to producing this absolutely wonderful wine???
Just when you’re ready to give up on ever enjoying  a chardonnay that actually reaches it’s enormous potential….bam, pow wee.. you taste something that renews your faith in the unpredictability of wine.
So there I was in a restaurant called Frank’s at Pawley’s Island, escaping from the brutal frigidity of
Charleston to bask in the near temperate climes of North Cack-a-lacky when, to my lips, I placed a glass of chardonnay.

Hoakey Smokes! The stuff was subtle, creamy, rich yet balanced, and tasted like the fruit of a grape called… chardonnay!  And no, this was not a $200 bottle of white Burgundy or even some trophy wine from Napa. It is the 2007 ZD (California) Chardonnay.

At about $25 a bottle, the wine has a “California” appellation, meaning that the grapes for it could have come from anywhere in the state – not necessarily a prime location like Carneros or Santa Rita Hills, Napa or Sonoma. 
I drank the wine with grilled grouper and the combination was a testament to the old axiom about the whole being greater than the sum of the parts. What a superb match.    
Lest I be misunderstood, I would not describe the wine as great. It is just very good and very true to the varietal grape – chardonnay – from which it was made.  However, in producing a wine that is the purest essence of chardonnay, ZD deserves kudos. 
Here are some other wineries that seem to produce balanced chardonnay year in and year out:  Chateau Monelena; Talley Vineyards; Acacia; Pine Ridge; Montes Alpha; Merryvale Starmont; and Alamos.
Go get you some!

Local Food and Wine Event

Friends of Wine and Food You might want to jump on this one right away. The FARM2U Collaborative is sponsoring a great food and wine event next Monday. See the invite below.

You’re invited! Come celebrate the culinary heritage of WV as guest Chefs from around the state join Berry Hills Country Club Chef Chad Rieve to create a unique, wine-paired five-course festival of food.

Monday, October 17 • Berry Hills Country Club • Reception- 6:30 – 7:30 • Dinner to follow Tickets: $100 per person, $175 per couple, or $1,000 for a VIP table of eight (8). (Table hosts will also receive 4 tickets to the Welcome Reception of the Cast Iron Cook-Off, January 21, 2012, at The Greenbrier).

The Food Antipasto Salad & Exotic Cheeses Harvest Soup Herbal Roasted Veal Rib Eye Russian Fingerling Potatoes Sherry Glaze Chanterelle Mushrooms Butternut Squash Duchess

Our Team of Executive Chefs• Tim Urbanic, Café Cimino • Anne Hart, Provence Market • Chad Rieve, Berry Hills Country Club • Dale Hawkins, Fish Hawk Acres • Paul Smith, Buzz Food Products

Tickets available on-line at www.wvfarm2u.org, or at The Purple Onion, Capitol Market. Seating is limited – advance purchase required.

Sponsored by the FARM2U Collaborative.For more information, contact Jack Cipoletti, 304-346-3351 or This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it..

I’m privileged to be a board member of the FARM2U Collaborative which does, among many other good deeds, a great job getting WV farmers together with state restaurants to provide the best foods to those of us who enjoy excellent local cuisine.

Give them a call today!

Falcor Winery: Charleston’s Napa Valley connection

Falcor Winery: Charleston’s Napa Valley connection

It’s not often many of us can have our dreams come true, but that’s pretty much the case for two Charleston lawyers whose love of wine has morphed from a passionate hobby to another full-time occupation.

While Mike Bee and Jim Petersen (at right) won’t be giving up their day jobs any time soon, the two local residents are spending a considerable amount of time in their second jobs as owners of a boutique Napa Valley Winery – Falcor. 

As enthusiastic wine lovers and regular visitors to California’s North Coast wine country, Bee and Petersen decided to take the plunge and start their own winery. After visiting Napa and talking to many people in the trade, the men were encouraged to modify their idea of building a full-fledged winery and begin their foray on a more modest scale.  
First they set about finding the right wine maker. A mutual friend introduced them to   Ray Coursen, then the winemaker at Napa Valley’s Whitehall Lane and now owner of Elyse Winery who agreed to take on the task.  Coursen is not only a fine wine maker, but is also familiar with many of Napa’s finest vineyards and is able to procure fruit from them for his (and Falcor’s) wines.
Their first wine was a 1996 full-bodied style Napa Valley Chardonnay. Mike and Jim were very pleased with the result and that led to a stable of limited production  wines (about 500 cases for each varietal) including two chardonnays, sangiovese, syrah, merlot, cabernet sauvignon, Le Bijou ( a Bordeaux-style blend), cabernet franc and a rose.
Mike’s son, Ryan, is now Falcor’s general manager and, in addition to his day-to-day duties, he oversaw the building of Falcor’s new winery and up-scale tasting room which opened last summer in the town of Napa. If you’re in the area, you can visit the winery at 2511 Napa Valley Corporate Drive, Suite 115 for a tasting of the wines. 
While Falcor wines are available at wine shops and fine restaurants throughout the state and the southeastern US, you may also order wines directly from the winery by calling 888-402-9463 or visiting the website at www.falcorwines.com.
I have reviewed a few of their wines in the past and today I’ll give you my impressions of the latest releases from Falcor.
2005 Durrell Vineyard Chardonnay ($42) – Grapes for this rich, full-bodied wine come from the Durrell vineyard in Sonoma County where renowned wineries Kistler and Patz & Hall also source their fruit. This wine shows flavors of ripe pear and creamy vanilla and will benefit from two to three years of bottle age. Try it with chicken cordon bleu or Chilean sea bass.
2005 Sangiovese ($35) – This Napa Valley wine is comprised of 88% sangiovese and 12% cabernet sauvignon. Medium-bodied, it is brick red in color and full of bright cherry and cinnamon flavors with a lingering finish. Excellent balance insures it will continue to improve over the next five years, but would be a great pairing now with a roasted veal chop.
2004 Syrah ($32) – Also from Napa, this wine has dark, juicy plum flavors with a hint of toasty oak. Stylistically, it reminds me of a big Barossa Shiraz and would marry nicely with marinated and grilled leg of lamb.
2003 Le Bijou ($40) – This Bordeaux blend of cabernet, cabernet franc, merlot and petit verdot is a symphony of flavors and always a favorite of mine. Complex with tack-room and spicy aromas, the wine has forward fruit and cola nuances and is well balanced. While drinkable now, it too will benefit from further aging. No question of the food match here:  grilled or roasted filet.
2003 Cabernet Franc ($38) – Ripe, rich , blackberry fruit with a touch of anise and toasty oak, this Napa wine is stylistically  more like a Chinon (from the Loire region of France) than a California wine – and that’s a good thing. Drink it with pork tenderloin that has been marinated in lemon juice, olive oil and rosemary and then roasted.
2005 Dry Creek ( Sonoma) Zinfandel ($36) – Like its Dry Creek Valley neighbors A. Rafinelli and Lytton Springs, the Falcor Zin is bursting with blackberry fruit typical of the area. Rounded out with a touch of oak, this wine will benefit from about three more years in the bottle. This wine needs baby back ribs slathered with a Kansas City style sauce.
2003 H. Block Cabernet Sauvignon ($65) – This is a special wine made from grapes grown around the town of St. Helena in the Napa Valley. It is a rich, full-throttle cabernet, but is well balanced with black currant and cola flavors with just a touch of oak. Decant it for an hour if you want to drink it now and serve it with roasted red meat or…with a “death by chocolate” dessert.  

Navigating the wine economy: Abstinence is not the answer!

In this depressing economy, where certain staples of existence such as food, fuel and shelter have all become more affordable, I have not yet seen a comparable drop in the price of wine. 

Oh, believe me, I am out searching the hinterlands each day for affordable sippers so you and I can continue to enjoy a glass of wine with our mac &cheese at the end of the work day.  But it’s not easy.

In ruminating about ways of economizing the wine budget, I’ve decided to suggest  several wine categories  for you to explore (according to price) in the hope  you’ll be able to find a wine to suit your palate and wallet too. So, here goes.

Vino Jigundo

First (and perhaps least appealing) would be to search the jugs, boxes and wine skins for the large volume products that are something more than colored water with the addition of grain alcohol.  I’m no snob, but most of this mass-produced plonk is,  at best, unappealing.

However, I am willing to work my way through the witch hazel to find that diamond in the rough.  If any of you out there in wine land have found any good, inexpensive, mass-produced wines, please let me hear from you (see comment section at the end of this post).

The Value Fifths

There are indeed some excellent wines in the $8 to $15 a bottle range and ,over the past couple of years, I have recommended dozens of them to you. The simple way of  finding these value wines is to go to your favorite wine shop and ask the folks there to direct you to those particular goodies.

Many of these bottles are unfamiliar to us and can hail from countries such as Spain, Austria and Portugal, but there are some lovely little ditties if you take the time to search for them. Albarino and rioja (Spain), gruner veltliner (Austria) and verdelho (Portugal) are just a few examples.

Saturday Night Second Fiddle Wines

I don’t know about you, but I consume  wine almost every night. However, I distinguish between weekday bottles  and “Saturday night” wines (which I sometimes have on Friday and/or even Sunday). Saturday night wines can be expensive – which means anything over $20 a bottle to this parsimonious wino.  Unfortunately, it is sometimes very difficult to find a reasonably priced Saturday night wine unless you go to the “second fiddle” stuff.

Simply put, second fiddle refers to those wines owned and produced by a more famous winery, and bottled under a second (different) label. These wines sell at a significantly more reasonable price and many times are made from the same grapes that produce the more famous label.  Other times, these second label wines can be made from grapes that are from a younger parcel of the same vineyard used to make the parent label.   


Here are some examples of some second label wines.  Alamos is the second label of  Catena (from
Argentina) and the chardonnay and cabernet produced is excellent and less than half the price of the more famous label.  Hawk’s Crest is Stag Leap’s second label, while Logan is Talbott’s and Gavilan is the second wine of Chalone – just to name a few.

If you really want to splurge on Saturday night, you might want to check out the second fiddle
Bordeaux from the following famous reds :

Ch. Gruaud-Larose - Sarget de Gruaud-Larose
Ch. Lafite Rotschild - Moulin des Carruades
Ch. Talbot-  Connetable Talbot
Ch. Pichon-Longueville-Lalande-  Reserve de la Comtesse
Ch. Haut-Brion -  Ch. Bahans-Haut-Brion
Ch. Lynch Bages- Haut-Bages-Averous
Ch. Latour -  Les Forts-de-Latour
Ch. Cos d'Estournel -  Marbuzet
Ch. Margaux - Pavillon Rouge de Chateau Margaux

The Red-Haired Step Child

Famous wines from equally famous wine regions are priced at stratospheric levels and so, in order to sample the region’s goodies, I often  invoke the red-haired step child rule. For example,  I really do love the wines of Piedmont in northern Italy, but I don’t want to pay $80 to $200 a bottle to drink the world class Barolo and Barberesco produced there. Instead, I’ll buy an $18 bottle of Barbera or a $15 Spanna (which is actually made from the same grape – nebbiolo -  that produces Barolo or Barbaresco) or even a Dolcetto in all its frothy glory.

Instead of Chateauneuf du Pape or Hermitage, I’ll opt for Gigondas or the wines of Vaucluse, both of which are made from the same blend of grapes that produce the more famous wines of the Rhone region. In California, where cabernet and chardonnay are king and queen  respectively,  I will sip zinfandel, pinot blanc or even  that scourge of the movie “Sideways” – merlot. 

So do not despair and don’t even contemplate abstinence. Times may be tough, but there are many reasonably priced and tasty wines to see us through.

There’s more to Beaujolais than Nouveau!

I bet when most folks think of Beaujolais, they think of that frothy, grapy new wine called Beaujolais Nouveau that is released with great fanfare in France each year around the middle of November.

Beaujolais Nouveau is a fun wine full of fresh strawberry fruit flavors (it’s only about two months old when it arrives) that is more a celebration than an exercise in fine wine drinking.  Most Nouveau is relatively inexpensive (around $10 to $15 a bottle) and is meant to be drunk within the year after bottling. 

In the last decade or so, importers have gotten Nouveau to the US within a day or two of its release in France, and so now we Americans also celebrate the “new” wine. In fact, a few local wine shops have Beaujolais Nouveau “barrel” tastings each November.

Today I’ll tell you about the other Beaujolais wines that, while less known, are considered far superior to Nouveau. Don’t get me wrong. I really do enjoy Beaujolais Nouveau in all its frothy, fruity glory. However, I think most folks don’t realize there are also some serious wines being made in this region just to the south of Burgundy.

Beaujolais is produced from a grape called gamay. Gamay is a lighter pigmented red grape that, when allowed to soak for extended periods on its skins, can produce a medium and, in some rare instances, full bodied wine.

Beaujolais lies just south of the Macon region of Burgundy. From there, it descends south along a 34-mile stretch of rolling hills and ends near the famous Rhone wine region of Cote Rotie.  In addition to Beaujolais Nouveau, you will see wines labeled Beaujolais, Beaujolais Superior or Beaujolais Villages and these can be decent to very good wines. While I do enjoy these wines, the best of Beaujolais are much more serious wines and some can actually improve with bottle age for up to ten years. 

The best wines of the Beaujolais region are known as Cru (which means “growths” in French).  Crus are named after the villages around which the grapes are grown.  There are ten Cru Beaujolais. You may see a wine labeled Morgon (the name of a Cru village) in large type with the year and producer (i.e., “Georges Duboeuf”) in smaller type.

The ten Cru Beaujolais are:  Brouilly, Chenas, Chiroubles, Cote de Brouilly, Fleurie, Julienas, Morgon, Moulin-a-Vent, Regnie and Saint Amour. Each of these Crus produces distinctly different Beaujolais from very light and delicate (i.e., Chiroubles and Fleurie) to fuller-bodied wines (i.e., Moulin a Vent and Morgon).

Like Burgundy, it is very important to select your Beaujolais from reputable producers and shippers. Among the most prominent of these are:  Joseph Drouhin, Duboeuf, Louis Jadot, Louis Latour, Prosper Maufoux, Bouchard Pere et Fils and St. Vincent. Unlike Burgundy, Cru Beaujolais is reasonable priced ($15-$30 a bottle).   

In matching the wine to food, I suggest you use the Crus Beaujolais like you would a light to medium-bodied pinot noir.  The beauty of the wine the gamay grape produces to me is its deep floral qualities and cherry, berry flavors. I particularly like to pair a good Moulin a Vent with roast tenderloin of pork.